The Big problem with Katich Stats is the Strike Rate. Most games he just wasted balls where others were getting strike rates of 90+.

Name..... Mat I NO Runs HS.. Ave.. SR.. 100 50 Ct St
SM Katich 10 10 1, 413, 107* 45.88 68.71 1, 4, 3, -


He is in the there for 1 reason and that is the hard tough games where not many runs are scored ... but he is a liability in the games where we need to score 300+ as he just can't bat that quickly. Jaques on the other hand is IMO a more exciting and better player, but may not be the right player to play with Gilchrist. I would probably drop Katich or Clarke (its a tough choice) and replace them with Jacques. At this stage I would drop Katich.

My 12 would be

Jaques
Gilchrist
Ponting
Symonds
Hussey
Clarke
Lee
Bracken
Macgill
Tait
Clark

Super Sub : Watson