Just one more bit of info which could change how the final selections would be made.

A, 73 selections, +$30.59 profit, 54% S/R, 41.9% POT (Not controllable when I'm inputting my selections)
B, 47 selections, +$23.29 profit, 59% S/R, 49.5% POT (Fully controllable)
C, 21 selections, +$21.88 profit, 80% S/R, 104% POT (Not controllable when I'm inputting my selections)
or D, Leave as is - 136 selections, +$25.90 profit, 45% S/R, 18.5% POT (Fully controllable)

Does that make a difference?