EI - have to agree with you there. I have no problems with people wanting to keep their systems and/or selections to themselves but I don't understand people who just post "that will not win" without any explanation - either their idea of what the winner will be or a justification for why the other selection wont win (eg. wont carry the weight or go the distance, etc). Certainly doesn't contribute anything to the forum to simply post "you're wrong" without anything to back it up!