It's time the umpires were stripped of the job of doing the votes.
If Judd's season was twice as good as Tredrea's then I give up.

Anyone familiar with AFL Dream Team?
Judd only ranked 25th. I know not a true reflection but these guys ranked above him.

1st Lappin
2nd Riewoldt
3rd West
6th Tredrea
9th Haselby
10th White
16th Hall
17th Ricciuto
23rd Cornes

Anyway, I'm glad Tredrea didn't win as I follow Adelaide so I hate Port. Still think he was the best player this year.