2005 Futures based on Sportnut ratings.

Footy Team - 8 - 4 - GF - Prem

Port Power 1.01 1.15 1.80 2.70
St Kilda ... 1.03 1.30 2.25 3.80
West Coast 1.05 1.40 2.75 5.20
Geelong ... 1.25 2.70 5.60 12
Sydney ... 1.25 2.50 6.10 15
Brisbane .. 1.50 4.20 8.50 20
Carlton .. 1.65 5.20 13.5 40
Melbourne. 2.10 8.90 20.0 50
Collingw'd 2.20 9.70 25.0 80
Essendon . 2.30 10.6 27.0 80
Fremantle. 2.75 16.0 40.0 100
Adelaide . 3.20 20.0 50.0 150
Kangaroos. 17.0 300. 1000 none
Bulldogs .. 22.0 500. 1000 none
Richmond . 100. none none none
Hawthorn . 250. none none none

Your ratings suggest that there are only 3 contenders this year,but you're formula assessed prices give chances to many no hopers.
Your personal prices are much closer but still somewhat generous with the top 3.
Even disregarding hindsight,a major error seems to have been made in Brisbanes assessed rating.Especially when it comes up with $1.50 to make the 8.