Well here's a comparison with the the top 3 picks from the Courier Mail poll for Bris, Syd, Melb.

Bris
Forum tipsters poll: 4 winners ($9.00, $3.60, $6.10, $12.50)
Courier Mail poll: 2 winners ($11.90, $3.60)

Syd
Forum tipsters poll: 4 winners ($2.30, $3.10, $6.90, $4.40)
Courier Mail poll: 6 winners ($2.30, $3.10, $3.60, $8.50, $6.90, $4.40)

Melb
Forum tipsters poll: 6 winners ($2.10, $6.40, $3.10, $3.60, $3.60, $4.50)
Courier Mail poll: 5 winners ($2.10, $6.40, $3.10, $3.60, $3.60)