As far as Scenic Peak is concerned, I simply forgave him that run. For a start it was on a dead track at MV. Secondly the horse is a model of consitency and his previous form this campaign was right up to his best. I assessed him on his Toorak 2nd. Thats the real Scenic Peak.

Mr Magoo: another consistent horse. Look at his ratings on Ozeform. His MV rating was light years below his true form.

I don't follow any hard and fast rules when it comes to a bad run, its a case by case decision. If a horse is generally consistent, and his previous form this prep is a true indication of his ability, I'll forgive them a bad run.

It doesnt always work, Hosannah is an example. Her form has kept declining since her win on Oct 5.