I agree with both points of view actually.

1. Neil has always done a terrific job with the newsletter and site in general.

2. A greater balance of positive and negative comments in the newsletter might be more interesting.

3. If Neil created a newsletter filled with positives, then that too would be very boring.

4. Hopefully some of the comments in the newsletter will actually be seen by some of the offenders, as they are kept in archives on this site.
As such they may actually be shamed into changing their ways!

Keep up the good work.