She got 50.5 in the cups for 2001. My point was more that surely the Bris cup is a lower class race than caul/melb and she has only had 7 starts since the oaks win, 4 or 5 of which were completely unsuitable and in all of the starts the shortest price was 9/1, so obviously others also thought the races were unsuitable. I am not casting aspersions on the handicapper merely questioning whether it is fair to downgrade a horse that has its best performance two years ago but only a handful of starts?

I won't be betting until the day or at least the field and barriers are drawn after a bad experience previously.