Wes, thanks again, I'm surprised. as WA seems to be much better than that, but my research is limited.

travelrock, yes I hear you, but it seems that even the absolute masters of ratings can't show a profit so I wonder where I stand???

I think you'll find most profitable punters DO RATINGS.

I'm not sure which master you are referring to. Perhaps Don Scott? The guys at R&S knew him and they say his methods are profitable if used in a disclipined way.

There are some stories about Don Scott that he got cleaned out at the end of his life. I don't know how true that was, but if he was making money for over a decade then his methods did work and any subsequent results are probably more to do with emotions than method.

Where do you stand?

Stay away from tipsters and do ratings.

agreed