Sportz and co, what are your thoughts for the aussie test and one day day, considering most people are bagging the selectors these days?

My thoughts are:

One Day:
1 Gilchrist
2 Jaques
3 Ponting
4 Martyn
5 Symonds
6 Clarke
7 Hussey
8 Hogg
9 Lee
10 Tait
11 McGrath

SS Hopes

Reserves: Johnson, Cullen


Test:
1 Hayden
2 Jaques
3 Ponting
4 Martyn
5 Hussey
6 Symonds
7 Gilchrist
8 Warne
9 Lee
10 MacGill
11 McGrath

Reserves: Bracken, Langer

Chuck,

Well I am convinved Katich lost us the game last night. Way too slow for a one day batsman.

Anyway I only have a couple of changes to your sides ...

One Day:
1 Gilchrist
2 Jaques
3 Ponting
4 Watson
5 Symonds
6 Clarke
7 Hussey
8 MacGill
9 Lee
10 Tait
11 McGrath

Test :
1.Hayden
2 Katich
3 Ponting
4 Jaques
5 Hussey
6 Symonds
7 Gilchrist
8 Warne
9 Lee
10 Tait
11 McGrath

They have the bulk of the side ok but I think they just don't have the fringe players quite right yet.